Arthur Carmona is dead. He died Sunday morning when he was struck by a truck following a loud argument at a party in Santa Ana. Carmona gained notoriety in 2000 when he was released from prison after 2 1/2 years when evidence showed that he had been wrongfully convicted of the armed robbery of an Irvine juice bar in 1998. To gain his release as quickly as possible, Carmona signed a promise not to sue. His lawyers, friends of mine who worked in the same office I did, contended that the promise was invalid, and filed a major civil rights case on his behalf in U.S. District Court (his defense lawyer at trial was an acquaintance, too). I never had a chance to talk with the young man. I don't his legal team really wanted him talking to the other lawyers in the office, but I did meet him casually, and it was obvious to me that he was one very angry young man. I could understand why. I'd have been angry, too. Maybe I, too, would have let my anger put me in bad, even dangerous situations. Maybe I would have let prison kill me eight years after my release.
Though they did not seek a retrial, the District Attorney's office continued to assert that he was guilty of the crime. Ultimately, his lawsuit was thrown out on summary judgment, and his appeal was denied. He was angry about the conviction, angry about the prison time, and angry about never being made good for the injustice. A few years after his convictions were lifted, he got into trouble again, over a parking lot dispute that left two cars, including his, severely vandalized. The news reports suggest that his murder on Sunday came after some sort of confrontation. Maybe that isn't it at all, however. His family told reporters that Arthur had turned his life around finally. “When he got out of jail, he went through a lot of ups and downs,” his mother said, but "he had found purpose and he was finally moving on.” His uncle told reporters “He was doing very well. He was a joyful, outgoing kind of guy. He was always happy and had lots of friends.”
Recent Comments